Scarlet Letter Scaffold Scenes Analysis Essay

Recurring events show great significance and elucidate the truth beneath appearances.  In The Scarlet Letter Nathaniel Hawthorne chooses the scaffold scenes to show powerful differences and similarities.  Each scaffold scene foreshadows the next and brings greater understanding of the novel. By beginning with the first, continuing with the middle, and ending with the last platform scene, we can gain a better understanding of this masterpiece.

At the beginning of the book, Hester is brought out with Pearl to stand on the scaffold.  Here the scarlet letter is revealed to all.  Reverend Dimmesdale, Pearl’s Father, is already raised up on a platform to the same height as Hester and Pearl; and Roger Chillingworth, Hester’s lost husband, arrives, stands below and questions the proceedings.  As Hester endures her suffering, Dimmesdale is told to beseech the woman to confess. It was said “So powerful seemed the ministers appeal that the people could not believe but that Hester Prynne would speak out the guilty name.”  His powerful speech shows Dimmesdale’s need to confess.  This scene sets the stage for the next two scenes.

A few years later the event is again repeated.  It is very similar to the other and helps us understand the torment of Dimmesdale.

As before the tortured Reverend Dimmesdale goes first on to the platform.  He seeks a confession of his sins a second time by calling out into the night. He then sees Hester and Pearl coming down the street from the governor’s house.  As before, they are asked to go up on the scaffold and be with the minister.  At this time Pearl questions the minister if he will do this at noontide and he answers no.  He once again is too much of a coward to confess out in the open. The similarities continue with a revelation of another scarlet letter. Up in the sky a scarlet “A” shines forth.  Roger Chillingworth arrives and tells the minister to get down from the scaffold.  Chillingworth pleads for this so that he can still torment the reverend.  As the two men leave, the scene ends and leaves us with additional information.  It foreshadows a bigger and more powerful scaffold scene.

The last scaffold scene is the most important and greatest event in the novel.

It starts with the end of Dimmesdale’s great election speech.  When he is finished, he grows weak and limps towards the scaffold.  He can no longer bear the burden of his sins.  He again asks Hester and Pearl to join him.  Chillingworth begs the minister not to do this, but the reverend thanks God for leading him to a place where he could escape from the leech.  Helped by Hester and Pearl he climbs the scaffold and confesses.  One last time a new scarlet letter is supposedly revealed on his chest.  This voluntary confession makes this time unique.  As the scene ends Dimmesdale again leaves Hester and Pearl; but this time, it is forever into the afterlife.

These three important events in the novel have great significance.  The first one signifies love.  Hester had such strong love that she would not make Dimmesdale go through what she was going through.  The second scaffold scene signifies cowardice.  The reverend was suffering much and yet would not relieve his suffering through confession.  The ending event signifies bravery.  Even though he didn’t have to confess, Dimmesdale did.

The Scarlet Letter’s recurring event was very potent.  It gave new aspects and meanings to the story that were integral to the book’s power.  Truth overcomes deception.

Analysis of The Scarlet Letter Scaffolding Scenes

Get Your
Essay Written

Starting at Just $13.90 a page

AP English 9 September, 2012 Analysis of the Three Scaffold Scenes In Hawthorne’s novel The Scarlet Letter, there are three detailed scaffold scenes, each of which embody significant descriptive elements and ultimately unite the book as a whole. The three eminent elements found amongst these scenes are the four main character’s physical appearances, behaviors and demeanors. Through these characters, Hawthorne suggests valid points about goodness, sin, and guilt, which are encoded in the form of symbols, signs, and events.

The first scaffold scene is verbally focused upon Hester and the scarlet letter, but when dissected and viewed through an analytical lens, Hawthorne endows his audience with an amassment of other character and plot based elements. Hester Prynne is depicted as a beautiful young woman in this scene with “dark abundant hair” and a lady like affinity. The irony weaved within this is that people are not paying attention to her outward appearance, for they are only gathering around her to observe the scarlet letter for themselves.

One of the first descriptions shortly prior to the actual scaffold scene is of the scarlet letter pinned upon Hester’s bosom; it is a red “A” brilliantly embroidered by Hester herself with gold thread, thus creating a gorgeous piece of embroidery. The beauty of the scarlet letter drastically contrasts with its shameful recognition of adultery, analogous to how Hester is beautiful, yet burdened with the ownership to an ignominious affair. The “scarlet letter” is literally a symbol intended to mark Hester’s sin.

Through its beautiful and bold design, it is conveyed to the reader that Hester is not hiding behind denial, nor afraid to accept the branding mark of her unbiblical actions, which are also blatantly represented by sin. However, goodness is also prevalent through Hester’s behavior. When Dimmesdale asked who her lover was, Hester refuses to capitulate and makes the noble decision to keep his name covert, thus sacrificing her body to wear the scarlet letter forever. It is Hester’s demeanor in this scaffold scene that symbolizes her utter guilt.

Hawthorne writes, “Had a roar of laughter burst from the multitude–each man, each woman, each little shrill-voiced child, contributing their individual parts–Hester Prynne might have repaid them all with a bitter and disdainful smile. But, under the leaden infliction which it was her doom to endure, she felt, at moments, as if she must needs shriek out with the full power of her lungs, and cast herself from the scaffold down upon the ground, or else go mad at once. ”(Hawthorne 52-53) This quote explains how Hester’s guilt and frustration does threaten to exalt from within her as a cacophony of screams.

However, instead of appeasing to society and breaking down, she locks her broken feelings of guilt within herself and allows it to fabricate a callous demeanor. Mr. Dimmesdale is delineated as a young man with a high set white brow leaving an apprehensive look on his face, trembling lips that he forcefully clenched through his own self restraint, and large brown eyes that were described as “melancholy. ” These worrisome features were directly caused by the guilt of his own denial slowly gnawing away at his heart.

It is clearly stated that his facial expressions differ from those of Hester’s even though they both committed the same sin, but why? Well, Hester is considered the publicly know sinner in this scenario, thus she does not feel the same perpetual guilt that Dimmesdale does for being too cowardly to confess his sins. However, while lecturing Hester he exclaims, “If thou feelest it to be for thy soul’s peace, and that thy earthly punishment will thereby be made more effectual to salvation, I charge thee to speak out the name of thy fellow-sinner and fellow-sufferer! (Hawthorne 62) Dimmesdale said this hoping that Hester would be strong enough to expose the hidden sin that he could not find the courage to confess, but due to her still existing feelings for Dimmesdale, Hester repudiates his demands. Although his attempts to publicly repent fail, there is goodness found within Dimmesdale’s intentions. Lastly, guilt and anguish completely compose Dimmesdale’s demeanor in the first scaffold scene, and it is easily detected upon his face. As the pain from his bitter ignominy augments within him, he clutches his heart to assuage the searing burn.

During this first scaffold scene Pearl is just a small infant, but acts as a symbol of goodness, guilt, and sin. Due to the fact that she is a baby, Pearl withholds an innocence associated with goodness. However, the child is a product of sin and externally symbolizes her parent’s frowned upon affair. Pearl’s parents also both experience the feeling of guilt for their actions throughout this scene. Although they brought upon the guilt by themselves, Pearl is innately the image of their regret. The last important character that is involved in these scenes is Roger Chillingwortth. At this point in the novel, he is haracterized as a short middle aged man with an intelligent physique and is identified by his uneven shoulders and slightly deformed figure. It is referenced multiple times that Chillingworth is comparable to the devil in both his appearance and demeanor, thus directly making him a symbol of sin. This scaffold scene is the initiative spark that ignites his obsession to find the man who has betrayed him. He makes eye contact with Hester at one point and signals her to keep his anonymity by casting his finger over his lips. Also, Chillingworth played the part as a stranger and asked another townsman who Hester was and what she had done.

He also hollered, “But he will be known! -he will be known! -he will be known! ”(Hawthorne 58) foreshadowing his persistent search for the man who had sinned against him. At the end of the scene, Chillingworth is caught up in a vengeful state of mind as the thought of revealing the secret sinner’s identity consumes him. The second scaffold scenes main purpose is to exemplify Dimmesdale’s utter agony and inner struggles relating to his veiling ignominy. Hawthorne adds in a variety of symbols that seem to emphasize the guilt causing Dimmesdale to internally writhe in pain.

Hester Prynne arrives to the second scaffold scene a little while after Dimmesdale had cried out in repentance. She was attired in her ordinary clothing with Pearl by her side as always. Dimmesdale spots little Pearl and calls her and Hester over to the scaffold to join him and link hands. The “A” is once again resurfaced when Hawthorne writes, “And there stood the minister, with his hand over his heart; and Hester Prynne, with the embroidered letter glimmering on her bosom; and little Pearl, herself a symbol, and the connecting link between the two of them. (Hawthorne 144), but this time it is symbolizing goodness through the reunion of Hester, Dimmesdale, and their daughter. It is interesting how Hester stands upon the very same scaffold that she had stood upon seven years prior with the same two significant people, but this time she is listening to Dimmesdale confess his sins instead. In the second scaffold scene, Dimmesdale’s health has further deteriorated since his guilt has been slowly killing him from the inside out.

He exclaims how he wants to stand on the scaffold until the morning sun lightens the sky, but cannot because of the cold evening air irritating his arthritis and turning his throat raw. Hawthorne also describes Dimmesdale once again clutching his heart and resembling his guilt, which continues to fester inside of him and torment his soul. A meteor shower rains above Dimmesdale, Hester, and Pearl lighting up a red “A” in the sky, which is thought to represent the death of Governor Winthrop by all the townspeople, but Dimmesdale is acute enough to know better than to believe that.

He knows very well that the red “A” was displayed to resemble his silent, yet bold repentance of his sin. Although Dimmesdale makes progress towards repentance in this scene, when Pearl asks him to join her and Hester upon the scaffold publicly, Dimmesdale declines and tells her to wait until judgment day. This is another exemplification of Dimmesdale’s weakened morals and symbolizes his sin in the manner of which it is too powerful for him to dominate.

Dimmesdale sustains his melancholy and ill demeanor for the most part throughout this scene, but there is a slight aberration within him which he should be commended for; this was the first time he had ever truly confessed to his sins. Dimmesdale says himself, “Ye have both been here before, but I was not with you. Come up hither once again, and we will stand all three together! ” meaning that when he stood on the scaffold the first time he was not there to support Hester and little Pearl, but this time he wants to stand with them in union.

Although there were only a few people present to hear him boast in his weakness, he still stood upon the scaffold and spoke about his most wretched sin symbolizing a miniscule step in the direction of goodness. Pearl is significantly older in the second scaffold scene than she was in the first. At this point in the book, she has aged into a beautiful young child and strongly resembles her mother’s scarlet letter. Her innocence has eroded away and she is viewed through many strong allegorical lenses; her mother refers to her as a “living hieroglyphic” in the manner that Pearl constantly reminds Hester and Dimmesdale of their sin.

Society sees Pearl as the “devil’s work” since they perceive she was only made out of sin and not derived from the glory of God. While Dimmesdale is holding Pearl’s hand, she asks him to stand with Hester and her in front of the whole town on the scaffold, and when he declines she tries to pull her hand away. This small gesture is another action that indicates Pearl’s refusal to accept Dimmesdale until he admits he is her father to the public. Pearl maintains her usual clever and “elfish” demeanor during this scene symbolizing an untamable freedom that is unfathomable to the orthodox Puritan colony.

Hawthorne uses the meteor in the second scaffold scene to enhance the hideous features of Chillingworth. It is interesting how the light from the meteor that formed the scarlet “A” in the sky made his unappealing appearance intensified because it is analogous to Chillingworth’s relationship with the scarlet letter; the sense of betrayal and sin that the scarlet letter has shed upon Chillingworth has changed him into a fiend and ugly old man consumed by the need to have a victim.

There are also instances within this scene directly comparing Chillingworth to the devil such as when Hawthorne writes, “Certainly, if the meteor up the sky, and disclosed the earth, with an awfulness that admonished Hester Prynne and the clergyman of the day of judgment, then might Roger Chillingworth have passed with them for the arch-fiend, standing there, with a smile and scowl, to claim his own. ” (Hawthorne 145) This excerpt undeviatingly makes a connection between Chillingworth and sin as the devil is perhaps the most symbolic reference to sin and evil.

Also, Chillingworth witnesses Dimmesdale, Hester, and Pearl’s reunion under the cloak of darkness, which confirms his suspicions of Dimmesdale being Hester’s mutual sinner and escalates his revenge. When Chillingworth is finally discerned by Pearl, he acts as if he has simply come to bring Dimmesdale back to their house, contributing to his cunning and deceitful demeanor. Once again, Chillingworth has distinguished himself as a man living out of betrayal and malevolence.

The third and final scaffold scene illustrates Dimmesdales full repentance of his sin, thus casting change upon all of the main characters. Through his repentance Dimmesdale salvages his soul from the guilt, ameliorates Hester of her burden, unites Pearl to her humanity, and rids Chillingworth of his victim. Over the course of the seven years between the first and third scaffold scene, Hester’s appearance drastically changes. In the beginning of the book, she is illustrated as a beautiful young woman, but through the years her beauty has essentially vanished along with all of her qualities of femininity.

Previous to the third scaffold scene, Hawthorne states, “If she survive, the tenderness will either be crushed out of her, or—and the outward semblance is the same—crushed so deeply into her heart that it can never show itself more. ”(Hawthorne 152) Hester’s homely physical appearance at the third scaffold scene resembles her loss of tenderness due to her years spent living in sin. After Dimmesdale makes his public confession, Hester gingerly holds his head and asks him if they will spend eternity together now that they have endured the suffering for their sins.

Dimmesdale replies that God knows what they have done and had blessed them both with the torture to help navigate their way to repentance, but they would not spend eternity together in heaven. This is resembled years later when Hester is buried near Dimmesdale, but instead of sharing a grave, they only share a tombstone. This is comparable to that fact that Hest and Dimmesdale are both in heaven, but are not there as a united pair, thus exemplifying that even after her sin is forgiven Hester is forever forced to face the consequences.

Hester’s demeanor after this scene changes as her dream of being with Dimmesdale becomes utterly impossible for her to fulfill. This unfortunate fate is an honest representation of God’s eternal punishment towards sin. Years after Hester’s disappearance from the Puritan colony, she returns to her previous position as the isolated sinner and reclaims her ownership to the scarlet letter by wearing it on her bosom once again. This represents her reluctance to let her sin go because woven within the caustic strands of her wrong doings laid her only connection to her true love.

Dimmesdale is the main focus of this particular scene as his self-acceptance towards his sin seems to progress in the right direction through each scaffold scene. In the third scaffold scene, Dimmesdale’s physical appearance is described, “The glow, which they had just before beheld burning on his cheek, was extinguished, like a flame that sinks down hopelessly among the late-decaying embers. ” (Hawthorne 235) basically defining him as a man on his death bed.

This description demonstrates the severe destruction that guilt can cause a person over time if the penance is not fully endured. As if a very popular figure standing on a scaffold in a crowd of people is not captivating enough, it is said that the sun shone down upon him and illuminated his figure, setting him apart from the rest of the scenery. Also, Hawthorne includes a part in this scene when Dimmesdale rips open his shirt to reveal a scarlet letter similar to Hester’s, but permanently carved into his skin.

Dimmesdale heroically states while speaking about himself, “He tells you, that, with all its mysterious horror, it is but the shadow of what he bears on his own breast, and that even this, his own red stigma, is no more than the type of what has seared his inmost heart! ”(Hawthorne 240) Through saying this, Dimmesdale insists that Hester’s scarlet letter is nothing but a shadow of his own sin, therefore fully admitting to his breach in the commandments of God.

This symbolizes goodness, as Dimmesdale has finally taken some of the public burden off Hester’s shoulders. Although Dimmesdale is finally ridden from his sin, he dies immediately after his repentance from the massive amounts of damage that had been caused over the past seven years. Dimmesdale dies with a righteous demeanor once he had come to the conclusion that all of his suffering was a blessing from God because it has brought him to repentance, thus saving his soul.

Through his last words, Dimmesdale represented goodness as he conveyed to the townspeople that God does not see different degrees of sin, but sees everyone as sinners in need of his salvation. Although Pearl’s physical appearance does not change during the small time increment between the second and third scaffold scenes, her personality transforms as she finally finds humanity within herself. Before this scene, Pearl had been living her life simply to torture her parents, while obsessing over the idea of surfacing the truth. Pearl makes a significant change after Dimmesdale repents and confesses his sin.

Hawthorne writes, “The great scene of grief, in which the wild infant bore a part, had developed all her sympathies; and as her tears fell upon her father’s cheek, they were the pledge that she would grow up amid human joy and sorrow, nor for ever do battle with the world, but be a woman in it. ” (Hawthorne 240) suggesting that Pearl has finally accepted Dimmesdale as her earthly father, which liberates herself of her “elfish” qualities and allows her to develop a more sensitive demeanor and the humanistic trait of sympathy.

Once described as a direct product of sin, Pearl is now portrayed as a human capable of living a pure life and symbolizes the journey from a world of sin to goodness. After Dimmesdale falls to the ground while standing on the scaffold, it is said that, “Old Roger Chillingworth kneeled down next to him, his face blank and dull, as though the life had drained out of it. ” (Hawthorne 240) Directly after Chillingworth kneeled down next to Dimmesdale, he screams, “You have escaped me! (Hawthorne 240) multiple times meaning that Dimmesdale has escaped playing the role of Chillingworth’s victim. This also foreshadows Chillingworth’s death that occurs soon after Dimmesdale dies. It turns out that Chillingworth’s only reason to live anymore was to victimize Dimmesdale and relentlessly torture him, resembling sin in the most basic manner. When Dimmesdale dies, so does Chillingworth’s purpose of life; a villain cannot exist without his victim.

Also, when Dimmesdale calls Hester and Pearl up onto the scaffold, Chillingworth practically begs him to stay silent and claims that he can still save Dimmesdale. The apprehension in Chillingworth’s actions and the expressions that are illustrated upon his face leaves Chillingworth with a defeated demeanor. It goes without explanation that Hawthorne purposely made the three scaffold scenes the most prominent and dramatic chapters in The Scarlet Letter, but they also unite the entire book together in more than one fashion.

The most blatantly clear tactic that Hawthorne uses to unite the novel is that he incorporates each of the four main characters into all three scaffold scenes. This is beneficial to the novel because it allows Hawthorne to verbally illustrate dramatic scenes that pertain to each character individually. Also, Hawthorne uses the time in between the scaffold scenes to allow the effects of goodness, sin, and guilt to seep into the characters and bring about change.

Hawthorne used Hester to symbolize sin and the tragic circumstances that can occur even after repentance, just like he used Dimmesdale to symbolize the effects of hidden guilt throughout each scaffold scene, Pearl to symbolize the scarlet letter itself and the goodness of finding humanity, and Chillingworth to symbolize intentional sin and the devil. Also, the scaffold scenes unite the book because Hawthorne can place all four main characters into the same situation, yet have them each play a different role, thus each character is affected in a diverse, but related way.

Lastly, Hawthorne unites the book through the scaffold scenes by showing Dimmesdale’s progression towards repentance, and by correlating his health status to the amount of time that his soul had been eroded by guilt. Throughout the entire book, Dimmesdale was battling with his lack of courage towards repentance, but the only times he made progress was while he was at the scaffold.

Do you like
this material?Get help to write a similar one

When the final scaffold scene ends, all of the four characters have either lost or gained a significant piece to human life; Dimmesdale had finally regained his soul, Hester watched her dream and desire vanish before her, Pearl finally discovered her humanity, and Chillingworth had lost his victim. This is significant to the rest of the novel because it allows the reader to make connections in between the front and back covers of Hawthorne’s masterpiece, thus deepening their understanding of the symbolic and literal references. Work Cited Hawthorne, Nathaniel. The Scarlet Letter. Pleasantville, NY: Reader’s Digest Association, 1984. Print.

Author: Brandon Johnson

in The Scarlet Letter

Analysis of The Scarlet Letter Scaffolding Scenes

We have so large base of authors that we can prepare a unique summary of any book. Don't believe? Check it!

How fast would you like to get it?

Categories: 1

0 Replies to “Scarlet Letter Scaffold Scenes Analysis Essay”

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *